Favoriting Bodega Pop with Gary Sullivan: Playlist from July 12, 2023 Favoriting

Gary's avatar View Gary's profile Favoriting

Sounds ripped from cassettes & CDs found in immigrant-run mom & pop stores. Deconstructed icons. Field recordings. Sonic mayhem from the far corners of the internet.

Wednesday 7 - 10pm (EST) | On WFMU's Give the Drummer Radio
Give the Drummer Radio LIVE Audio Streams (Get help):   Pop-up  |  128k MP3

<-- Previous playlist | Back to Bodega Pop with Gary Sullivan playlists | Next playlist -->


Favoriting July 12, 2023: In His One Languages
Post-exotica cultural appropriation, collaboration, provocation, hybridization, disorientation, and pure imagination, from Bollywood's amorphized manifestations of "other" to contemporary art projects redefining identity in a world of infinite availability

Listen to this show: Pop-up listen Pop-up player!

Playlist image Favoriting

This show relies heavily on suggestions from Drummer Stream compadres Robert Brainen, David Mittleman, Charlie Lewis, Jeff Golick, Philip Levy (Stork), Evan Crankshaw (Flashstrap), Stream Master Doug Schulkind, David Weinstein, and Tony Coulter

Artist Track Album Year Comments Approx. start time

Music behind DJ:
Bodega Pop 

Introduction   Favoriting

Bodega Pop 

2023 

 

0:00:00 (Pop-up)
Technical Space Composer's Crew  Boat Woman Song   Favoriting Holger Czukay & Rolf Dammers  1969    0:04:50 (Pop-up)
Lata Mangeshkar | Laxmikant-Pyaralal  Aa Jaane Jaan   Favoriting Inteqam OST  1969    0:22:23 (Pop-up)
Barney Wilen  Wah Wah   Favoriting Moshi Too  2013  Recorded 1969-70, previously unreleased  0:29:08 (Pop-up)
Malagasy et Jef Gilson  Malagasy   Favoriting Malagasy  1972    0:36:07 (Pop-up)
Aktuala  Mud   Favoriting La Terra  1974    0:43:11 (Pop-up)
General Strike  Parts of My Body   Favoriting Danger in Paradise  1979    0:51:05 (Pop-up)
Futuro Antico  Track 3   Favoriting Isole Del Suono  1980    0:53:56 (Pop-up)

Music behind DJ:
Emerson Kitamura 

The Countryside Is Great   Favoriting

The Countryside Is Great 

2018 

 

1:00:42 (Pop-up)
Jon Hassell  Data Bintung at Jelong   Favoriting Dream Theory In Malaya (Fourth World Volume Two)  1981    1:09:26 (Pop-up)
African Head Charge  Stebeni's Theme   Favoriting My Life in a Hole in the Ground  1981    1:17:05 (Pop-up)
Brian Eno & David Byrne  Qu'ran   Favoriting My Life in the Bush of Ghosts  1981    1:20:24 (Pop-up)
Jacky McKayten ג'קי מקייטן  Qurbani קורבני   Favoriting The Black Magic הקסם השחור  1982    1:23:58 (Pop-up)
The Sun Ra Arkestra  Egypt Strut   Favoriting In Egypt  1983    1:28:23 (Pop-up)
Jean-Michel Jarre  Ethnicolor   Favoriting Zoolook  1984    1:34:57 (Pop-up)
Finis Africae  Zoo Zulu   Favoriting Finis Africae  1985    1:46:26 (Pop-up)
Kavita Krishnamurthy & Chorus | Laxmikant-Pyarelal  Hawa Hawai   Favoriting Mr. India OST  1986    1:51:20 (Pop-up)
Nirodh Fortini, Walter Maioli, Fred Gales, Raffaele Serra, John Zandijk, Edward Luyken  Side B (Excerpt)   Favoriting Ethnoelectronics  1986    1:58:14 (Pop-up)
Hector Zazou  La Poursuite   Favoriting Reivax au Bongo  1986    2:00:08 (Pop-up)
Roberto Musci & Giovanni Venosta  Tamatave   Favoriting Urban and Tribal Portraits  1988    2:02:34 (Pop-up)
Haruomi Hosono  Caravan   Favoriting Omni Sight Seeing  1989    2:06:57 (Pop-up)

Music behind DJ:
Emerson Kitamura 

Lam Phloen Salab Khonsawan Bassline   Favoriting

The Countryside Is Great 

2018 

 

2:10:52 (Pop-up)
Paolo Modugno  Visioni di Pietra   Favoriting La Bala et la Mouche  1994    2:25:39 (Pop-up)
Muslimgauze  Turn on Arabic American Radio   Favoriting Turn on Arabic American Radio  2022  Recorded in the late 80s or 1990s  2:32:36 (Pop-up)
Naujawanan Baidar  Khyber Sound (From Kabul To Peshawar In Fullmoon)   Favoriting Naujawanan Baidar  2018    2:42:59 (Pop-up)
Antropoloops  Ronda en la noche del exilio   Favoriting Mix Nostrum  2019    2:48:00 (Pop-up)

Music behind DJ:
Catrina Peslaru 

Hei La Bodega   Favoriting

Hei La Bodega - Carnaval! 

2000 

 

2:57:09 (Pop-up)


<-- Previous playlist | Back to Bodega Pop with Gary Sullivan playlists | Next playlist -->

RSS feeds for Bodega Pop with Gary Sullivan: RSSPlaylists feed | RSSMP3 archives feed

| E-mail Gary Sullivan | Other WFMU Playlists | All artists played by Bodega Pop with Gary Sullivan |

Listen on the Internet | Contact Us | Music & Programs | WFMU Home Page | Support Us | FAQ

Live Audio Streams for Give the Drummer Radio: Pop-up | 128k MP3    (More streams: [+])


Listener comments!

  6:56pm
Jill B.:

Goof Evening Gary!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 6:58pm
listener james from westwood:

Evening, Gary and all!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:00pm
Gary:

Hi, Mom! Hi, James!
Avatar 🇰🇷 Swag For Life Member 7:00pm
Threemoons 🌛🌕🌜:

Heyo! Gotta make dinner between work/estate/other stuff calls. Looking forward to the set!
  7:00pm
peter:

hey there Gary & all!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:01pm
Gary:

Hi, Threemoons! Hi, Peter!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:01pm
pot8o:

hi everyone!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:01pm
Gary:

Hi, Pot8o!
Avatar 7:01pm
emily_w:

Here on time for once!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:01pm
Gary:

Hi, Emily!
Avatar 🇰🇷 7:03pm
Listener Gregory:

Good evening, Gary and the Hot Bods!
I also got My Life in the Bush of Ghosts when it was first released, but, sadly, not "as a kid."
Avatar 7:03pm
TDK60:

Hi Gary.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:03pm
pot8o:

anyone have some good recommendations for jordanian stuff? looked through habibi funk's discography (and a few other labels similar to it) and no dice
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:06pm
Gary:

↳ Listener Gregory @7:03
Gregory! When I say "kid," I mean under 20 -- I think I was 18 or 19 when I bought the album, haha
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:06pm
Gary:

TDK60 and Gregory, Hi!
Avatar 7:07pm
TDK60:

A friend came over enthusiastically with the new "Bush" LP to turn me onto it. He also brought a hallucinogen. Yeah.
Avatar 7:07pm
tim abdellah:

Heya Gary and friends!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:08pm
Gary:

Hi, Tim!
Avatar 7:09pm
tim abdellah:

I got Bush of Ghosts as a "kid" too!
Avatar 🇰🇷 7:11pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Gary @7:06
Yeah... I was not, though.
  7:13pm
chresti:

Hi Gary bodega show!
Avatar 🇰🇷 7:14pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Song: "Boat Woman Song" by "Technical Space Composer's C...
Sorry, I missed who these boat women are. They are knocking it dead.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:15pm
Gary:

Hi, Chresti!
Avatar 7:17pm
slugluv1313:

hiya Gary! Everyone!
listening while i finish up with the EVIL LAUNDRY
unfortunately missed your intro! but, i got My Life in the Bush of Ghosts when it was released -- my last year in college, so i was a kid too, sort of :)
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:18pm
Gary:

Hi, Slugluv1313!
Avatar 🇰🇷 7:18pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Jill B. @6:56
Jill, you and I can sit in the senior citizens section. I hope we get a discount!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:19pm
coelacanth∅:

good evening Gary and all
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:21pm
Gary:

Hi, Coelacanth!
Avatar 7:24pm
emily_w:

Such a good song
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:25pm
Gary:

Emily, I trust you have not only heard the song before, but seen the scene it is picturized on ... and quite likely the whole movie as well
Avatar 7:26pm
emily_w:

I haven't seen the movie yet!! But yes I have seen the picturization, haha!
Avatar 7:27pm
emily_w:

Helen forever
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:27pm
Gary:

I've noticed that Shemaroo & others have taken down scenes that used to be available on YouTube w/out question -- now, you never know if it's still there. YES! Do you have, by the way, the Helen book? I gotta go see if I can find it to give you the title, if not
Avatar 7:28pm
emily_w:

I haven't read it yet but they have it at my library! Thanks for reminding me about it because I've been meaning to get to it for ages...
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:30pm
Gary:

I'm afraid because I just checked and it's not on the shelf where it should be. :( ... I read it a long time ago and only remember the part about Helen and her mother's long journey from Burma to India as refugees
Avatar 🇰🇷 7:30pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Song: "Wah Wah" by "Barney Wilen"
Is this Barney Wilen, the French saxophonist??? (If I remember correctly.)
  7:30pm
Dean:

Was 21 when I acquired MLITBOG. Not a (wo)man, not a child.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:31pm
Gary:

↳ Listener Gregory @7:30
Yes!
Avatar 🇰🇷 7:31pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Gary @7:31
Crazy. Most famous here for one album with Miles Davis.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:34pm
Gary:

↳ Listener Gregory @7:31
Oh, i didn't know that -- what Miles album was he on?
Avatar 🇰🇷 7:36pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Listener Gregory @7:31
French soundtrack for Ascenseur pour 'échafaud. Apparently doing this soundtrack gave Miles the idea for the much freer approach that he took with his "Second Quintet." Don't get me started on this, people! en.wikipedia.org...
Avatar 7:47pm
TDK60:

Pretty groovy to have a show with suggestions from other DJs.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:48pm
Gary:

↳ TDK60 @7:47
Great for me, especially, because I get to hear a lotta new-to-me stuff
Avatar 🇰🇷 Swag For Life Member 7:59pm
WR:

hi Gary and Bodegans.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 7:59pm
Gary:

Hi, WR!
  8:01pm
peter:

hey i know this backing tune ;)
Avatar 🇰🇷 Swag For Life Member 8:02pm
Revolution Rabbit Nov63:

Hullo !
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:05pm
coelacanth∅:

well - if you decide that the decade begins on the first day of 1080, then that's when it begins.
(for that matter, if you decide it begins on june 21, 1984, then THAT is when it begins)
Avatar 8:06pm
emily_w:

You've definitely seen more than me, Gary! I've watched about 300 Indian films since I started keeping track.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:06pm
coelacanth∅:

(1980, that is...not 1080... although that applies too)
Avatar 8:09pm
emily_w:

Definitely agree that that's one of the greatest Lata songs too!
Avatar 8:09pm
TDK60:

Jon Hassell, always a pleasure. I usually turn up the volume when he's on. Still sounds futuristic often.
  8:11pm
Dean:

Now I get it. MLITBOG is ground zero for post-exotica cultural appropriation...?

MLITBOG is just about the *only* music by either Eno or Byrne I can tolerate. On the other hand, I can listen to Hassell anytime. (Even this Eno-related thing.)

What are the parameters for exotica? I've been playing recorder duets with a teacher (she's now playing flute, too), and we recently had fun with Henry Cowell's "Pelog." Seems like appropriation to me.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:11pm
Gary:

↳ TDK60 @8:09
I gotta say, Evan was on the nose to suggest this particular LP
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:12pm
Listener Gregory:

Gary, I am sure that the conversation on Twitter will be sophisticated and nuanced, as well as being sympathetic to everyone's views.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:12pm
Gary:

↳ Dean @8:11
Man, see, that's a question with a bottomless answer, Dean!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:12pm
Gary:

↳ Listener Gregory @8:12
Definitely now that that guy that builds the flaming cars and complains about work-from-home is managing it!
  8:14pm
Dean:

Well, Cowell died in late '65, and Denny was doing his thing from the late '50s. It's likely Cowell was not "post-" the arrival of the genre in popular culture.
  8:19pm
Dean:

Anybody suggest Rema-Rema, "Wheel In the Roses"? Seems apt.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:20pm
Gary:

↳ Dean @8:19
No, I don't know what that is!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:21pm
zzz:

hey @Gary and all, enticing show summary. enjoying the african head charge and byrne/eno so far
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:21pm
Gary:

ZZZ!
Avatar 8:21pm
tim abdellah:

↳ Song: "Qu'ran" by "Brian Eno & David Byrne"
This track sparks heated debates still
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:22pm
Gary:

↳ tim abdellah @8:21
Yes! That's why I had to play it specifically -- also because it was removed from subsequent editions
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:23pm
pot8o:

↳ tim abdellah @8:21
which is a shame, as it's the best track on the album

mea culpa is a very close second
Avatar 8:23pm
tim abdellah:

↳ pot8o @8:23
As a Muslim, I'm glad they removed the track.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:24pm
Gary:

↳ Song: "Qurbani קורבני" by "Jacky McKayten ג'קי מקייטן"
Emily, do you recognize this one?
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:25pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ tim abdellah @8:23
It does seem wise.
  8:25pm
Dean:

Oh, dear. Do explore.
https://www.discogs.com/master/17533-Rema-Rema-Wheel-In-The-Roses
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:26pm
pot8o:

↳ tim abdellah @8:23
that's fair

i wish they had gone somewhere in the middle and removed the qu'ran sample
Avatar 8:27pm
emily_w:

↳ Gary @8:24
It sounds so familiar but I can't quite place it!!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:27pm
Gary:

↳ pot8o @8:26
That would have been a good compromise, Pot8o
Avatar 8:29pm
emily_w:

Ah of course it's from Qurbani, another one I've been meaning to watch, especially since Zeenat Aman was recently talking about it on her Instagram (she's the best)
Avatar 8:29pm
tim abdellah:

I had some belly dancer friends who once performed a routine to a track from a Turkish music compilation called "The Holy Qur'an". It was pointed out to them that the use of that particular track would not be considered appropriate, so the stopped using it 😅
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:30pm
Gary:

Zeenat Aman is on Instagraom?!?
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:30pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Song: "Egypt Strut" by "The Sun Ra Arkestra"
Before we accuse Sun Ra of appropriation, I would like to note that I believe he helped to build the pyramids before his 20th-century manifestation.
Avatar 8:30pm
emily_w:

Gary, yes!!! She is the best person on there pretty much. Just joined earlier this year and posts amazing reflections on her life and career.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:30pm
Gary:

↳ Listener Gregory @8:30
This is collaboration, Dean!
Avatar 8:31pm
emily_w:

www.instagram.com...
  8:31pm
Dean:

I have never been a First Amendment absolutist, largely because I read the amendment as a symptom of Founding Father passive aggression. But I can't quite understand why David Byrne and Brian Eno (or, for that matter, Two Live Crew) need to restrict--even only to the point of compromise--offensiveness of their work.

But then I'm a *fan* of cultural appropriation.
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:31pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Gary @8:30
Dean and I are collaborating on our comments. You really have no idea which of us is saying what.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:32pm
Gary:

↳ emily_w @8:31
Oh My Word! She's even more beautiful than I remembered, haha
Avatar 8:33pm
emily_w:

↳ Gary @8:32
Yes, so stunning!
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:34pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Dean @8:31
I don't know about "need to" restrict their work, but they may not have realized in 1981 just what offense might be taken, or perhaps not wanted that to interfere with the rest of their work.
  8:36pm
Dean:

You're right, LG. But not realizing the risk of offense and not wanting to invite inconvenience are two very different factors.
Avatar 8:37pm
tim abdellah:

↳ Listener Gregory @8:34
It's my understanding that they didn't realize that setting the Qur'an recitation with musical sounds would be considered offensive, and once they understood that they chose to withdraw the track.
  8:37pm
Dean:

Anyway, offense is awesome! I can't count how many times a day I'm offended (and held back and silenced) by something or other. I don't enjoy it, but at least it means I'm sentient. Offense comes with the territory.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:38pm
coelacanth∅:

regarding Hassell's problem with my life in the bush of ghosts, (i got a call just as about to post >20 minutes ago)
what i read was Hassell thought it was very commercial, and "pop" sounding...which, relatively, it was - even if a huge jump at the time for most mainstream music listeners.
in any case he and Eno came to a peace and Hassell softened his views considerably.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:38pm
Gary:

↳ tim abdellah @8:37
That sounds right, Tim, though I don't know the story, myself, or at what point it was decided
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:39pm
pot8o:

↳ Listener Gregory @8:34
plus iirc a council of british imams came out & released a statement against it, which is what caused eno & byrne to remove it
  8:39pm
Dean:

That, coelacanth∅:, seems entirely plausible.
Avatar 8:39pm
TDK60:

↳ coelacanth∅ @8:38
Odd, coel. I didn't think it commercial. But I'm probably elsewhere on the human sound spectrum from Mr. Hassell.
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:39pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ tim abdellah @8:37
That's what I imagined, though I had no idea. It may be hard to remember how little Americans knew about Islam in those days. (I realize Eno is English; I can't speak to that.)
  8:40pm
Dean:

So I guess Salman Rushdie, whom I've never read and don't particularly care to read, should have withdrawn his book?
  8:41pm
Dean:

(Look at what you've gotten into, Gary.)
  8:42pm
peter:

↳ Song: "Ethnicolor" by "Jean-Michel Jarre"
speaking of Jarres and cross-cultural collaboration/appropriation, i always thought Maurice's soundtrack to The Year of Living Dangerously (with its Indonesian influence) was very good
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:42pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ coelacanth∅ @8:38
The album may have been "pop" in some sense, but it only reached #44 on the Billboard charts in the US (Wiki). But it made it all the way to #8 in New Zealand! Yeah, Kiwis!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:43pm
Gary:

↳ peter @8:42
Oh, I need to hear that!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:44pm
coelacanth∅:

↳ TDK60 @8:39
yeah no it really wasn't, but for Hassell i guess it was, having "pop" things like hooks and riffs and catchy rhythms
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:44pm
Gary:

↳ Dean @8:40
Well, that's different because he was being provocative but also is from the culture itself -- not saying one way or another whether he should have withdrawn the book, but that the dynamics are significantly different
Avatar 8:45pm
tim abdellah:

↳ Dean @8:40
I've also never read Rushdie, but I understand that The Satanic Verses draws deeply and intentionally on some points in Islamic and Qur'anic history. Byrne and Eno seem to have stumbled into the controversy.
Avatar 8:50pm
TDK60:

↳ Song: "Zoo Zulu" by "Finis Africae"
This sounds influenced by Byrne & Eno. Maybe. A few years later.
Avatar 🇰🇷 8:51pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Song: "Zoo Zulu" by "Finis Africae"
Hmmm. Not feeling this. It sounds like a random incorporation.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:52pm
Gary:

↳ Song: "Hawa Hawai" by "Kavita Krishnamurthy & Chorus | L...
This track is related to the film still at the top of the playlist page
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:54pm
Gary:

↳ Gary @8:52
Much (but not all) of the lyrics are made-up language
  8:54pm
Dean:

I'm sorry, but I can't discern a difference. The "culture" has utterly porous boundaries, is ultimately impossible to delineate, never mind that indicia of intention are extremely difficult to specify. Now, if we want to deploy a regime whose job is to delineate the boundaries, establish intentions, and enforce violations, then that will take some very hard work.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:54pm
Gary:

↳ Gary @8:54
Especially the opening
Avatar 8:55pm
emily_w:

LOVE THIS SONG
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:56pm
Doug Schulkind:

L-P. What a team!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 8:57pm
Gary:

Hi, Doug!
Avatar 🇰🇷 9:10pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Song: "Caravan" by "Haruomi Hosono"
!!!
I just heard the Duke Ellington original of this tune. Never thought of the exoticism angle: Puerto Rican and Black writers, with lyrics by their Jewish American manager, on an Arabian theme.
Avatar 9:18pm
emily_w:

Anil Kapoor!
  9:19pm
Listener Gregory:

The men in the picture look like Little Richard imitators to me. Which they almost certainly are not.
Avatar 9:20pm
emily_w:

And the woman is Sridevi, she wasn't in softcore tho (maybe you're thinking of Silk Smitha?). Love Sridevi forever, she died so young and it makes me so sad.
Avatar 9:20pm
emily_w:

And yeah he was in Slumdog Millionaire haha
  9:22pm
Dean:

Jean-Michel Jarre had earlier releases. His pop was Maurice.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:23pm
coelacanth∅:

↳ Listener Gregory @9:19
maybe not *directly*
  9:25pm
Dean:

Than Oxygène, I mean.
Avatar 9:26pm
emily_w:

Sridevi did do a lot of sexy dance numbers for sure, but not softcore movies!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:29pm
Gary:

↳ emily_w @9:26
My sincere apologies to Sridevi for misinformationin' her like that
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:36pm
coelacanth∅:

so, if people, in their desire to feel righteous, call something like Jon Hassell, or Paul Simon, or Peter Gabriel, etc etc "cultural appropriation", shouldn't they also be accusing all rappers, all rock bands from africa, all arabic and african music that has piano or violin in it... Fela, Najma, Ceatano Veloso, Haruomi Hosono, Tracy Chapman . . . .?
  9:38pm
Dean:

I don't know for sure, but I believe Bryn Jones was not Muslim.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:39pm
Gary:

↳ coelacanth∅ @9:36
I don't think there is any escaping the permeability of music, is the argument here, but there are then, of course, instances and consequences of certain instances
Avatar 🇰🇷 9:40pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ coelacanth∅ @9:23
God only knows what is going on there.
Avatar 9:41pm
emily_w:

Gotta head out, thanks for a great show Gary!!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:44pm
Gary:

Always super-thrill to see you, Emily!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:45pm
Gary:

Hey Kids! Stick around after this program for the always-already thrill-tastic Sam Segal and If You Lose Your Horse! Tonight's episode: "There Are Still Horses and Goats, to Mention Only Them" wfmu.org...
Avatar 9:47pm
TDK60:

↳ Song: "Khyber Sound (From Kabul To Peshawar In Fullmoon)...
This sounds similar to Savage Republic or maybe Swans.
  9:48pm
Dean:

Those "instances and consequences" are *at most* marginally promoted by artistic appropriations. And I believe that prohibiting artistic efforts will accrue benefits to governing authorities to the point that the costs will far outweigh the benefits.

Is Qu'ran" offensive because it exists? It's aired frequently on radio? Somebody uses it intentionally to offend believers?
Avatar 9:49pm
TDK60:

Thanks, Gary, and Drummer Radio suggesters!
Avatar 9:49pm
tim abdellah:

↳ coelacanth∅ @9:36
Musicians always appropriate, grab influences, licks, whole songs from elsewhere and others. Still, unequal power relations are often at play and may be worth considering when analyzing a musical borrowing.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:50pm
Gary:

↳ tim abdellah @9:49
Yes, thank you, Tim
Avatar 9:51pm
slugluv1313:

↳ Song: "Khyber Sound (From Kabul To Peshawar In Fullmoon)...
your whole show has been absolutely fascinating, but this is exceptionally beautiful -- thanks so much!
Avatar 🇰🇷 9:54pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Dean @9:48
Dean, you talk about prohibiting artistic effort and establishing regimes, but I haven't heard anyone here suggest such things. People have the freedom to be offensive and also to avoid saying or doing something because it will cause offense. Arguing over whether the latter is appropriate is just part of the free speech deal. I am permitted to say all kinds of things, but I don't, and I probably should say less than I do. It's worth discussing whether X is worth the offense or is even offensive at all or creates a problem, etc., etc. Otherwise, we would have very little to talk about!

Nonetheless, I appreciate your contribution to this discussion.
Avatar 🇰🇷 Swag For Life Member 9:55pm
WR:

Thank you! Gary!
  9:56pm
Dean:

Unequal power relations are *always* at play and are *always* worth considering. Why is that a question?

But do Byrne/Eno have excessive "power" in this respect? No. They're two piddling players in a huge musical "ecosystem" (a metaphor I don't especially appreciate). If they want to crib from the Koran, who cares? (Answer: some folks, but mostly nobody.)
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:56pm
pot8o:

thanks gary! have a great week everyone!
Avatar 🇰🇷 9:56pm
Listener Gregory:

I have just realized that when people type, "Thank you, Gary!" I can pretend that they have simply mis-typed "Thank you, Gregory!" Nice.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:57pm
coelacanth∅:

↳ tim abdellah @9:49
i do appreciate that consideration, in general. i also think it has no place in art, which has no political boundary. if someone creates their own something -aural or visual decoration to get around paying someone for an authentic something, then Fuck them...
but being influenced by music and incorporating it into your own is not "appropriation". it's life. it's art and it's Love.
it's tribute. and it's evolution.
and most of the music that's been called the "victim" has "culturally appropriated" from something before it.
Avatar 🇰🇷 9:57pm
Listener Gregory:

↳ Dean @9:56
Fortunately, they had the choice of putting in the clip and then had the choice of taking it out. So far as has been reported, no one made them do either.
Avatar 9:58pm
tim abdellah:

↳ Dean @9:48
For me personally, I find beautiful the way that Islamic tradition has set apart Qur'an recitation from music. It recognizes the enchanting power that melody and rhythm can wield, and it attempts to set the audition of the word of God as a sonic experience separate from human musical activity. A Qur'an reciter who is praised for having a beautiful voice has failed as their job as a reciter, because the experience should be about the MESSAGE not the messenger (reciter).

I don't think anyone should be censored for setting the qur'an to music, but I think the deep tradition and thought behind the Islamic tradition of Qur'an recitation is worth understanding and considering.
Avatar 🇰🇷 Swag For Life Member 9:58pm
Revolution Rabbit Nov63:

~ TY Always DJ Gary ~
Avatar 9:58pm
slugluv1313:

↳ tim abdellah @9:49
so true -- like with food, there is always so much overlap . . . when i was studying North African/Middle Eastern dance, one thing i learned is that as long as you approach with respect, learning from another culture need not be this bad thing . . . there were articles about "why are white women stealing 'belly dance'" etc. . . . on the other hand, my Capoeira instructor's Dad had huge classes in Sweden (iirc) . . . and not to mention all the non-Japanese people who train in Karate!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 9:59pm
coelacanth∅:

...blues artists didn't create the blues; rappers didn't create rap, etc.
Avatar 🇰🇷 9:59pm
Listener Gregory:

Thanks a lot, Gregory! Whoops, I mean Gary! Great idea for a show, and it produced some great music.
I honestly think that all of us should be canceled for listening to this show. Then we can form our own Twitter-replacement app that will be moderated by Dean.
  9:59pm
Dean:

tim @9:58, I can't agree more emphatically.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 10:00pm
Gary:

Night, everyone!
Avatar 10:00pm
tim abdellah:

Thanks Gary for the grooves and all for the conversation - appreciate you all!
Avatar Swag For Life Member 10:05pm
coelacanth∅:

↳ tim abdellah @9:58
this probably is little justification for you, but i'd bet that track opened a lot of people up to exactly what you're saying.
i personally would, in consideration of what you say here, like to see the track included but with a note about it, maybe including an apology... but this is going back in time.
Avatar Swag For Life Member 10:06pm
coelacanth∅:

Thanks Gary!
Bottom
Comment!
Name
Email
(C) 2024 WFMU. Generated by KenzoDB, written 2000-2024 by Ken Garson